Nadia Turner is 17 and grieving her mother’s suicide when she sleeps with the pastor’s son, Luke. It’s just a tryst and the two aren’t in love. But when Nadia discovers that she is pregnant, choices are made that affect her life – and Luke’s – forever. When Nadia’s best friend, Aubrey, falls in love with Luke a few years later, secrets are exposed and the characters wonder if they will always be haunted by the choices they made when they were younger, and what would have happened had they chosen differently?